لیست کامل نمرات Gears of Wars: Judgments منتشر شد. لیست کامل را در زیر مشاهده می کنید:

IGN – 9.2/10
Destructoid – 9/10
GodisaGeek – 9/10
Eurogamer Italy – 9/10
XboxLife.dk – 9/10
Joystiq – 4.5/5
Xbox360Achievements – 8.9/10
NZ Gamers – 8.8/10
CheatCodeCentral – 4.8/5
InsideGamingDaily – 8.5/10
Strategy Informer – 8.5/10
GameTrailers – 81/100
OXM UK 8/10
OXM US – 8/10
Eurogamer – 8/10
Gamesradar – 4/5
The Escapist – 4/5
El33tOnline – 4/5
InsideGames – 79/100
NewGameNetwork – 77/100
Digital Trends – 7/10
The Sixth Axis – 7/10
VentureBeat – 7/10
GameReactor – 7/10
Eurogamer Sweden – 7/10
VideoGamer – 7/10
GiantBomb – 3/5
DigitalSpy – 3/5
Rev3Games – 3/5
Gamestalker.nl – ok